Choosing a derringer-style firearm for concealed carry is a decision demanding careful consideration. Both American Derringer and Bond Arms are prominent names in this market, each offering unique features and advantages. This in-depth comparison will help you understand the key differences and determine which best suits your needs and preferences.
Key Differences: Size, Caliber, and Features
While both manufacturers produce small, easily concealable firearms, several key distinctions exist:
Size and Weight:
-
American Derringer: Generally known for their slightly smaller and lighter models, particularly in their single-shot offerings. This makes them exceptionally easy to conceal, even in pocket carry. However, this compactness often translates to a slightly less comfortable grip.
-
Bond Arms: Bond Arms derringers are typically a bit larger and heavier, especially their double-barrel models. This added weight can contribute to better recoil management, but might make them less ideal for deep concealment in smaller pockets.
Caliber Options:
Both brands offer a range of calibers, but their availability differs:
-
American Derringer: Offers a wider variety of calibers in their larger models, including some less common options. However, their selection for smaller, single-shot models might be more limited.
-
Bond Arms: Known for a strong focus on popular calibers like .45 Colt, .410 bore, and 9mm, catering to a broader range of self-defense needs. Their caliber options are generally consistent across their model lines.
Action and Operation:
-
American Derringer: American Derringers primarily utilize break-open actions (single shot or double barrel). This typically translates to a simpler design, making them easier to maintain.
-
Bond Arms: Bond Arms also utilizes break-open actions but frequently incorporate features like their patented "Gripper" system for enhanced grip and safety. They also offer a slightly more advanced design, often with improved features for reloading.
Materials and Construction:
Both manufacturers use a range of materials, influencing durability and price.
-
American Derringer: Offers models constructed from various materials, including steel and aluminum. This impacts both the weight and the overall cost.
-
Bond Arms: Bond Arms frequently uses high-quality materials like stainless steel and aluminum alloys, known for resilience and longevity.
Choosing the Right Derringer: Consider These Factors
The ideal derringer depends heavily on individual needs and priorities:
-
Concealability: For ultimate concealment, the smaller size and lighter weight of certain American Derringer models might be preferable.
-
Caliber Preference: Consider the caliber's stopping power and your comfort level with recoil. Bond Arms' wider availability of popular calibers might be advantageous.
-
Ease of Use: American Derringer's simpler design might make it easier to learn and maintain.
-
Recoil Management: The added weight of a Bond Arms derringer could significantly reduce felt recoil, improving accuracy and shooter comfort.
-
Budget: Prices vary considerably between models and manufacturers. Research specific models from both brands to find one that fits your budget.
Conclusion: No Single "Best" Choice
There is no universally superior choice between American Derringer and Bond Arms. The best option hinges on individual needs and preferences. Thoroughly research specific models within each brand’s lineup, considering your priorities in terms of size, weight, caliber, ease of use, and budget. Always handle and test-fire any firearm before purchasing to ensure a comfortable and secure fit. Remember to prioritize safety and proper training in firearms handling.
