Are Shoulder Holsters Practical? A Comprehensive Look at Concealed Carry
Shoulder holsters have long held a romanticized place in popular culture, often depicted in films and television as the preferred method of concealed carry for detectives and undercover agents. But are they truly practical for everyday carry in the real world? The answer, as with most things, is nuanced and depends heavily on individual circumstances and priorities.
This article will delve into the pros and cons of shoulder holsters, examining their practicality in various situations and considering the alternatives available to modern concealed carriers.
The Allure of the Shoulder Holster: Advantages and Disadvantages
Advantages:
-
Concealment (in certain situations): Shoulder holsters can offer excellent concealment under a jacket or coat, especially for larger firearms. The weapon sits close to the body, making it less noticeable than other carry methods. This is particularly true in colder climates with heavier clothing.
-
Quick Access (potentially): With proper practice, a shoulder holster can allow for relatively quick access to your firearm. This is often touted as a major benefit, although speed of draw is highly dependent on individual skill and holster design.
-
Weight Distribution: The weight of the firearm is distributed across the shoulders, potentially reducing strain compared to other carry methods like appendix or waistband carry. This is especially beneficial for heavier firearms.
Disadvantages:
-
Complexity and Draw Stroke: Drawing from a shoulder holster requires a more complex and deliberate movement than other carry methods. This can be challenging under stress, and mastering the draw technique takes significant time and practice. A poorly executed draw can lead to injury or a failure to access the weapon when needed.
-
Printing: While potentially good for concealment under heavier clothing, shoulder holsters can "print" more easily than other options when wearing lighter attire, especially if the firearm is large. The bulk of the holster can be visible, even under a shirt.
-
Limited Mobility: Shoulder holsters can restrict movement, especially reaching overhead or twisting the torso. This can be inconvenient in everyday activities and potentially dangerous in a self-defense scenario where quick and agile movement is crucial.
-
Safety Concerns: Accidental discharge is a significant risk with shoulder holsters. The firearm is positioned near the body, and improper holster design or careless handling can lead to serious injury. Additionally, the holster itself can snag on clothing or other objects, potentially hindering a quick draw.
Alternatives to Shoulder Holsters: Modern Concealed Carry Options
The modern concealed carry market offers a wide range of holsters and carry methods. These include:
-
Inside the Waistband (IWB): Provides excellent concealment and is generally easier to draw from than a shoulder holster.
-
Outside the Waistband (OWB): Easier to access, but less concealment. Often preferred for open carry or when concealment isn't a priority.
-
Appendix Inside the Waistband (AIWB): Offers good concealment and a fast draw, but requires proper training and adjustment to avoid discomfort.
-
Pocket Carry: Ideal for smaller firearms and everyday situations. However, concealment can be challenging in some situations, and the draw may be slower.
-
Ankle Carry: Provides good concealment, but access is slower and can be uncomfortable for prolonged periods.
Conclusion: Practicality Depends on Your Needs
Ultimately, the practicality of a shoulder holster is highly subjective. While it might offer excellent concealment in specific circumstances, the complexity of the draw stroke, potential for safety issues, and restriction of movement often outweigh the benefits for most users. Modern alternatives like IWB and AIWB holsters offer superior comfort, concealability, and ease of access for the vast majority of concealed carriers.
Before considering a shoulder holster, thoroughly research different carry methods, receive professional training on safe firearm handling and drawing techniques, and assess your individual needs and circumstances to determine the most practical and effective carry method for you. Safety should always be the top priority when selecting a concealed carry system.
