Is .40 S&W Dead? A Comprehensive Look at the Caliber's Current Status
The question of whether the .40 Smith & Wesson (S&W) cartridge is "dead" is a complex one, sparking debate among firearms enthusiasts and professionals alike. While its popularity has undeniably waned in recent years, declaring it extinct would be a significant overstatement. Let's delve into the factors contributing to its perceived decline and examine its current relevance.
The Rise and Fall (and Potential Rise Again?) of the .40 S&W
The .40 S&W emerged in the early 1990s, touted as a compromise between the stopping power of the .45 ACP and the higher capacity of the 9mm. Law enforcement agencies quickly adopted it, drawn to its perceived balance of power and controllability. This widespread adoption fueled its popularity for a considerable period.
However, several factors have contributed to its decline:
-
9mm Advancements: Significant advancements in 9mm ammunition, particularly the development of more effective jacketed hollow point (JHP) rounds, have largely closed the gap in stopping power. Modern 9mm JHP rounds offer comparable terminal ballistics to .40 S&W, often with a considerable increase in capacity.
-
Recoil and Shootability: The .40 S&W's recoil is noticeably snappier than the 9mm, leading to faster fatigue and potentially impacting accuracy during rapid fire. For many shooters, the increased recoil doesn't justify the marginal increase in stopping power.
-
Cost: Ammunition for the .40 S&W is generally more expensive than 9mm, a considerable factor for both law enforcement and civilian shooters.
-
Shifting Law Enforcement Trends: Many police departments, initially enthusiastic adopters of the .40 S&W, have switched back to the 9mm due to the aforementioned advancements and cost considerations. This shift has significantly impacted the overall market demand.
Is it Truly Dead? A Look at the Current Landscape
While the .40 S&W's dominance has faded, it's far from obsolete. Several factors contribute to its continued presence:
-
Existing Inventory: A substantial number of .40 S&W firearms remain in circulation, both in law enforcement and civilian hands. This existing inventory ensures a continued market, albeit a smaller one.
-
Reliable Performance: The cartridge remains a reliable and effective round, capable of delivering sufficient stopping power in appropriate situations.
-
Continued Production: While production may not be as prolific as it once was, several manufacturers continue to produce .40 S&W ammunition and firearms.
-
Self-Defense Niche: The .40 S&W still holds a place in the self-defense market for those who prefer its perceived stopping power over the 9mm, particularly among those experienced with the caliber.
Conclusion: A Niche, but Not Extinct
In conclusion, while the .40 S&W may no longer be the dominant caliber it once was, it's premature to pronounce it "dead." Its popularity has undoubtedly declined due to advancements in other calibers and cost-effectiveness considerations. However, a significant number of firearms are still in use, and ammunition is still readily available, indicating its continued, albeit niche, relevance in the firearms market. The future might see a further reduction in its prevalence, but its complete disappearance seems unlikely in the foreseeable future.
