Choosing between the Remington 1187 and the 1100 can be tough for shotgun enthusiasts. Both are legendary names, but they cater to different needs and preferences. This comprehensive comparison will delve into the key differences, helping you decide which shotgun best fits your shooting style and budget.
A Quick Overview: Remington's Shotgun Titans
Before diving into specifics, let's quickly summarize the core characteristics of each model:
-
Remington 1100: A classic, gas-operated shotgun known for its reliability and smooth action. It's a workhorse, favored for its simplicity and proven performance. Many consider it a timeless design.
-
Remington 1187: A more modern, gas-operated shotgun featuring an improved, self-regulating gas system. It's designed for increased reliability with a wide range of ammunition and boasts a faster cycling action.
Key Differences: Dissecting the Details
Let's break down the critical differences that set these two Remington shotguns apart:
1. Operating System: Subtle but Significant Variations
Both shotguns utilize a gas-operated system, but the mechanisms differ slightly. The 1100 features a simpler gas system, requiring occasional cleaning to maintain optimal function. The 1187, on the other hand, boasts a self-regulating gas system designed to handle a broader range of ammunition types more reliably without requiring frequent adjustments or maintenance. This makes it more versatile, especially for hunters who use varying shell loads.
2. Cycling Speed and Reliability: A Matter of Modernization
The 1187's self-regulating gas system contributes to a noticeably faster cycling speed compared to the 1100. This faster cycling translates to quicker follow-up shots, a significant advantage in fast-action situations like sporting clays or hunting fast-moving game. While the 1100 is reliable, the 1187 is often considered more reliable across a wider variety of ammunition types and conditions.
3. Maintenance: Simplicity vs. Self-Regulation
The 1100's simpler design makes it easier to clean and maintain. However, this simplicity can also mean it's slightly more sensitive to the type of ammunition used and requires more frequent cleaning to maintain optimal performance. The 1187's self-regulating system reduces the need for frequent cleaning and adjustments, making it a more low-maintenance option for busy shooters.
4. Weight and Feel: A Subjective Comparison
The weight and feel of both shotguns are subjective; however, the 1100 is generally considered lighter, which some shooters appreciate for extended shooting sessions. The 1187 is slightly heavier, offering increased stability and reduced recoil for some. The best choice will depend on individual preferences and physical build.
5. Availability and Cost: Factors to Consider
Both the Remington 1100 and 1187 are readily available in the used market, although finding specific configurations or models might require some searching. Generally, the 1100, being an older model, can be found at more affordable prices. The 1187, being a newer design, might have a higher price point, particularly for newer or less-used models.
The Verdict: Which Shotgun Reigns Supreme?
There's no single "better" shotgun; the optimal choice depends entirely on your needs and preferences.
Choose the Remington 1100 if:
- You prioritize simplicity and ease of maintenance.
- You prefer a lighter shotgun for extended shooting.
- You're on a tighter budget and prioritize affordability.
- You primarily use one specific type of ammunition.
Choose the Remington 1187 if:
- You need a shotgun that reliably cycles a wider variety of ammunition.
- You prioritize faster cycling speed for quicker follow-up shots.
- You prefer a low-maintenance shotgun.
- You value increased reliability and versatility.
This comparison provides a detailed overview to guide your decision. Researching specific models and configurations within each series will further refine your understanding and help you make the most informed choice. Remember to handle both shotguns if possible before committing to a purchase to get a feel for which one best suits your shooting style.
