Choosing between the Smith & Wesson Model 586 and 686 can be a tough decision for revolver enthusiasts. Both are legendary .357 Magnum revolvers, renowned for their reliability and accuracy, but key differences exist that cater to distinct preferences and shooting styles. This in-depth comparison will help you determine which model best suits your needs.
Key Differences: Material and Weight
The most significant distinction lies in the construction material: the Model 586 boasts a heavier, all-steel construction, while the Model 686 utilizes a lighter, stainless steel frame. This difference translates directly into weight and handling characteristics.
-
Weight: The 586's heft significantly reduces felt recoil, making it more comfortable for extended shooting sessions and higher-powered ammunition. The 686, being lighter, is more easily carried concealed, although recoil will be more noticeable.
-
Maintenance: Stainless steel (686) requires less frequent cleaning and is more resistant to rust and corrosion, ideal for less-than-perfect storage conditions or outdoor use. The carbon steel (586) requires more diligent maintenance to prevent rust.
Performance and Accuracy: A Near Tie
Both revolvers are known for exceptional accuracy. Their robust designs and high-quality manufacturing ensure consistent performance. Minor variations in accuracy might exist between individual guns due to manufacturing tolerances, but generally, both models deliver similar levels of accuracy. The shooter's skill and the ammunition used will have a far greater impact on accuracy than the subtle differences between the 586 and 686.
Aesthetics and Personal Preference: A Matter of Style
The choice between a blued finish (586) and a stainless steel finish (686) often boils down to personal preference. The blued finish of the 586 offers a classic, traditional look, while the stainless steel finish of the 686 provides a more modern and durable appearance. Neither is inherently superior; the best choice depends on your individual style and intended use.
Practical Considerations: Concealed Carry and Everyday Use
-
Concealed Carry: The lighter weight of the 686 makes it a more practical choice for concealed carry. The added weight of the 586 can become cumbersome for all-day concealed carry.
-
Everyday Use: For target practice or recreational shooting, the 586's reduced recoil might be preferred, leading to a more enjoyable shooting experience. However, the 686's durability and ease of maintenance make it a suitable choice for everyday use, even in demanding conditions.
Which Model Should You Choose?
The optimal choice depends heavily on your priorities:
-
Choose the Model 586 if: You prioritize reduced recoil, prefer a classic look, and are willing to dedicate more time to maintenance.
-
Choose the Model 686 if: You need a lighter revolver for concealed carry, prefer low-maintenance stainless steel, and value durability and corrosion resistance.
Ultimately, both the S&W Model 586 and 686 are excellent revolvers. Carefully considering your individual needs and preferences will guide you to the perfect firearm for your shooting style and intended application. Handling both models at your local gun store is highly recommended before making a final decision.
