Choosing the right finish for your woodworking project can be a daunting task. Two popular options often debated are Tru-Oil and tung oil. While both are penetrating oils that enhance the beauty and protect the wood, they differ significantly in their composition, application, and final results. This detailed comparison will help you decide which oil best suits your needs.
Understanding the Differences: Tru-Oil vs. Tung Oil
The key distinction lies in their composition and drying process. Tru-Oil is a proprietary blend of drying oils, resins, and solvents, specifically formulated for gunstock finishing. It's known for its ease of application and buildable layers, resulting in a durable, glossy finish. Tung oil, on the other hand, is a natural oil extracted from the seeds of the tung tree. It's a slower-drying oil that penetrates deeply into the wood, offering excellent water resistance and a more natural, subtle sheen.
Chemical Composition:
- Tru-Oil: A complex mixture, including linseed oil, which is a common drying oil known for its durability, along with resins and solvents to accelerate the drying process and improve flow. The exact recipe is a trade secret.
- Tung Oil: Primarily composed of pure tung oil, a naturally occurring oil with high levels of unsaturated fatty acids, leading to its superior water resistance after curing. However, many commercially available products labeled "tung oil" are actually tung oil finishes, containing additives such as varnish or other resins. Be sure to check the label carefully.
Drying Time and Application:
- Tru-Oil: Dries relatively quickly, usually within 24 hours, allowing for multiple coats to be applied in a short timeframe. Its thin viscosity makes it easy to apply with a rag or brush, requiring minimal effort. Multiple thin coats are recommended for a superior finish.
- Tung Oil: Dries much slower, often requiring several days or even weeks between coats, depending on temperature and humidity. The curing process takes considerably longer than Tru-Oil. It also requires more coats to achieve a similar level of protection. Because it is thicker than Tru-Oil, the application might be trickier for beginners.
Durability and Water Resistance:
- Tru-Oil: Offers good durability and water resistance when properly applied with multiple coats. However, it's not as water-resistant as properly applied pure tung oil.
- Tung Oil: Known for its exceptional water resistance, especially when using 100% pure tung oil, providing superior protection against moisture damage. However, it requires more time and effort to achieve this protection due to the slower drying and the need for more coats.
Final Appearance and Sheen:
- Tru-Oil: Builds a smooth, durable, and glossy finish with multiple coats. You can control the level of gloss, from satin to high-gloss, by the number of coats.
- Tung Oil: Provides a more natural, subtle sheen that enhances the wood's grain while preserving its character. It leaves the wood looking more organic and less "finished".
Which Oil is Right for You?
The best choice depends on your project's requirements and your personal preferences:
-
Choose Tru-Oil if: You need a quick-drying, easy-to-apply finish with good durability, and you prefer a glossy finish. It's ideal for projects where time is a factor, like gunstocks or projects needing a quick turnaround.
-
Choose Tung Oil (pure) if: You prioritize exceptional water resistance and a more natural, low-sheen finish. It's perfect for outdoor furniture, cutting boards, or any project requiring maximum protection from moisture. Be prepared for a longer drying and application process.
Note: Always follow the manufacturer's instructions for both Tru-Oil and tung oil to achieve optimal results. Proper surface preparation is crucial for any oil finish to adhere correctly. Consider testing both oils on scrap wood to familiarize yourself with their application and drying characteristics before applying them to your final project.
